The Latin American Revolutions and the American Revolution both had similarities and differences. Both revolutions also caused many people to die. Was Winston Churchill a Nazi Sympathizer? Thomas Jefferson the author of the Declaration of Independence. Their common ideas placed them on common ground, which is why there are so many similarities between the two. << /Length 5 0 R /Filter /FlateDecode >> John Adams who signed the Declaration of Independence. Second, they both started by an uprising of people against unfair taxation by the monarchy. The American and French revolution were both extremely important in the changing path of world history. Again very good information! Human reason, they knew, was fallible. The American Revolution (1776) was the first revolution of the three. You guys definitely showed both wars were both very important. Both wanted to set up a Republic, which provided liberty and justice to all classes of citizens. The purpose of both of these revolutions was to overthrow their king. Although both revolutions look very similar to each other on the outside, for they were both trying to declare independence, in fact, there are more differences than there are similarities. . After many battles and months of unethical living conditions, the colonists won in victory and set in place America. And the problem that exists for some conservatives is the notion of corporate liberty, it is the all-or-nothing thinking that comes with reducing all liberty to individual liberty. The British victory in the French and Indian War had an enormous influence on North America, causing the colonies to become more unified and break away from Britains iron grip and causing much, Between the years 1750 - 1914, the American Revolution, French Revolution, and Haitian Revolution were all similar due to what sparked the revolutions and the social groups during, yet differed in the outcome of the revolutions. This did not go over well, and the nobles forced him to call a meeting of the Estates General (1789). Each of these revolutions was very complex, so any brief answer will be very incomplete. WebCompare American and French politics of the 18th and 19th centuries. One of the many differences between the American and French Revolutions is that, unlike the French, Americans did not fight for an abstraction. They mainly taxed the poor and because of this, many people went hungry. Haiti was a French colony and was the first European colony in Latin America to undergo a successful revolution (1804). This is what both the American and French revolutions were taking a stand against. Ultimately, the whole social construct reversed from French officials and les grands blancs on top and the slaves on the bottom to les grands blancs not being a part of society and the slaves on top. What did the Gilded Age reformers have in common with Jackson era reformers? The French Revolution wanted to change the style of government, while the Latin American Revolution was more focused towards gaining independence from a government. In both the American and French revolution, revolutionary groups stood up for themselves when taxed unfairly and began their journey down the revolutionary road with ideas of reformation and abolishment. In comparison, the first instances of declaring independence were used, not seen in the magnitude that they were declared in before. Between the years 1750 and 1914 the American Revolution the French Revolution and Haitian Revolution were all similar due to what sparked the revolution. The french people wanted Liberty- EQUALITY- Again, in Lockes Second Treatise of Civil Government it is stated that the people have the right to remove and replace their rulers along with individuals rights to life, liberty, and property. And all-or-nothing thinking approaches to individual liberty leads to tyranny. WebThere were similarities and differences between the French, American, and Haitian Revolutions. Thks happened multiple times during the French revolution. They had successfully won independence from Spain. Many socialists called that a Bourgeoisie dictatorship. This may have affected some decisions made by both in the revolutions as both had different outside influences. 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved, https://history.state.gov/milestones/1784-1800/haitian-rev, https://www.history.com/topics/british-history/enlightenment, https://www.gilderlehrman.org/user?destination=node/79031. That may sound like an oxymoron to you, but you described what it was. Shortly after the French Revolution, Haiti, a French colony, was inspired by the same ideals and had one of their own. Both also wanted to make their own Republic that spread new values of liberty and social equality., Unfortunately, these savages changed the outcome of how French citizens are treated, even today, without this revolution many citizens may still be contained within the Monarchy Laws. Though both revolutions have many relations, they both have many dissimilarities, throughout my work I will be displaying the reasons why both revolutions were similar and why they are different. The outcomes of independence movements in Haiti and the Spanish Americas were similar because they both ended successfully and with independence from the colonizing nation, a difference however was that in Haiti the revolution ended with a complete social overhaul and the re-arrangement of social classes whereas in the Latin American revolutions it ended as mostly the same as before. WebThe differences in the revolutions in America and Haiti are far more numerous than any similarities. All comments are moderated and must be civil, concise, and constructive to the conversation. This article informed so much about the American Revolution vs. French Revolution. The Great Similarities and Differences Between The French and American Revolutions. The American and French Revolutions were fought several years and an ocean apart. The American Revolution started out by not wanting bloodshed and violence. The major similarity they both shared were that the Revolution for both occurred in instances of the civilians rebelling against their government. This is yet another difference. Lastly, I will be concluding this discourse by stating the relevance of its implications to this very day. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Yes, the second paragraph of the American Declaration of Independence deals in abstractions and universal truths. A colony successfully won its own war against their mother nation, and became a newly formed independent country. Not only did America separate itself from its mother country, but it was the first country to overthrow its mother country., Human history is comprised of many strides against oppression and revolutionary upbringings. In Haiti, slaves were revolting in order to win their freedom and, eventually, to keep their freedom. The pursuit of Liberty is individual only, and it does not allow one to hamper or block anothers pursuit. WebThe French and American revolutions had so many similarities as well as differences. The French wanted nothing to do with their former government and based their government upon the new one that was formed by the American Colonies. Thomas Paine published a book titled Common Sense in 1776 in which he accused the British of the detrimental effect they imposed on Americans., The American Revolution resulted directly from attempts to reform the British Empire after the Seven Years War. The American Revolution was mainly a political revolution while the French revolution was a mix of political, social, and an economic revolution. The French Revolution and the Haitian Revolution are very similar in the ideals that drove them, the way they were carried out, and the things they achieved both through the revolutions themselves and their legacies today., However, this led to further uprising amongst the colonists such as the Boston Tea Party in 1773, which was the colonists attempt to abolish the Sugar Tax. For instance, French revolutionaries executed thousands and took over the lands of the Church and the aristocracy. Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts. That explains the differences. Overall, all three of these revolutions were influenced heavily by Enlightenment thought, but they were each politically different, with slightly dissimilar goals. The French and American revolutions were two revolutions that had the mind to change the government and to set up a democracy so that everyone could have equal rights. Utopian Fantasies vs. Real Happiness in Samuel Johnsons Rasselas, Why Modern Music Should Listen to the Past, Eating Alone: Aristotle & the Culture of the Meal, The Guns of February: Americas (Almost) Perfect War, Georgia OKeeffes Affection for Things: Thoughts on Cows Skull with Calico Roses, Imagination & Creation in the Poetry of Wallace Stevens, Alexander Hamilton, Number 15 and Number 6, in, James Madison, Number 20 and Number 52, in, Wendell Berry, Out of Your Car, Off Your Horse, in. Leon, Britains treasury was drained in order that they taxed America and infuriated the colonists; almost like the French treasury being low, in order that they declared war on alternative states to undertake to fill again the treasury; French, and War of American Independence had their own declarations and constitutions written. Violence - Latin America had violent wars - France had extreme and radical In addition, the the problems that plagued the French were some of the problems that bothered the Americans. How did the bravery and courage of men in America and France completely change the course of their countries future? The other word for this is communism. Or, if you will, democratic communism which in the end is an oxymoron. The American Revolution and French Revolution have differences as well. America: Devolution, Revolution, or Renewal? The French revolution, unlike the American Revolution, started out as an absolute monarchy and still was governed in a Middle Age fashion. John Locke wrote Two Treatise of Government (1690), which posited that all men are born equal with the unalienable rights of life, liberty, and property. Locke also said that a ruler should derive their right to rule from the consent of the people, and that the people should overthrow any ruler who did not preserve the peoples unalienable rights. The French revolution failed because removing those in power without replacing them with a proper leader is basically asking for a more corrupt leader to take over. WebSimilarities And Differences Between Latin American And Haitian Revolution 804 Words | 4 Pages. Enlightenment ideas were spread in the Salons of Paris, and with the advent of Gutenbergs printing press, Enlightenment texts were printed in the vernacular and circulated widely. Now, the American colonists were not represented in England because of their lack of presence. How was the Latin American Revolution different compared to Haitian, American, and the French? It was mainly composed of middle and upper class people. How does the saying "ang hindi lumingon sa pinanggalingan ay hindi makakarating sa paroroonan" relate to history? In Haiti, the insurgency of LOuverture was focused on racial equality and ending slavery. As French president Emmanuel Macron said, if you want to manage your own choice of society, your choice of civilization, you have to be able to be an acting part of this AI revolution . This example has been uploaded by a student. Even though these two revolutions started out similarly they also had many differences, Some of the main differences were how the civilizations dealt with the revolution., Revolutions have been momentous events in modern world history erupting on every inhabited continent except Australia (Lockard). By understanding the individual stories of each country, you can further your understanding of the similarities and differences between the two. The colonists who rebelled didnt kill King George III, while in the French Revolution they were also rebelling against their ruler but unlike the American colonists they beheaded their king Louis XVI. Between the years 1750 and 1914 the American Revolution the French Revolution and Haitian Revolution were all similar due to what sparked the revolution. Students will focus on analyzing message, purpose, and audience. Keep in mind that essays represent the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Imaginative Conservative or its editor or publisher. WebThe French revolutionaries were protesting a foreign colonial government, while the American revolutionaries were fighting against their own government. The beginning of the start of these revolutions were mainly due to the over taxation of put in place by political leaders for example Parliament in the case of the British American colonists and King Louis XVI and the nobles in the French Revolution and Haitian Revolution. That shows that the two revolutions are the same. Answer. In contrast to the similarities between the French Revolution and American Revolutions, the Americans were a colony that rebelled against their own government. Even enlightenment philosophe Voltaire criticized the French monarchy and the Church considering them representatives of tyranny. While ideas and perspectives may have differed in 17-1800s, it was about finding peace and prosperity as it did not exist in the colonies. However they differed in that there was no goal for social reform in the American Revolution, but in the Haitian Revolution the slaves had the goal of social reform of the rigid social class system. the differences between the American and French Revolution from a myriad of approaches. There is not one shred of evidence in the historical record that they believed they had founded either a national government or a permanent Union upon the Declarations self-evident truths. The American Revolution started in the year of 1775, and was set out to break away from Britain. That is because while individual liberty allows those who can to excel, it allows those who have excelled to limit and control others. That is, Americans fought for tangible goals; they fought to preserve their traditional rights rather than to overturn an established social order. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); The Imaginative Conservative is sponsored by The Free Enterprise Institute (a U.S. 501(c)3 tax exempt organization). Even the other ones in Latin America were led by Creoles (Spaniards who were born in Latin America). The lower class was unhappy with their unjust treatment and wanted change. Constitution, The French Declaration provided for a national defense, and emphasized equality before taxation which was distinctly different from traditional France, in which the Catholic Church and the nobility were exempt from most taxes. The separation and distance between Britain and the 13 colonies worked in favor for the colonists. In France, people revolted against the abuses of the French king and the very high taxes that the people had to pay. As for differences between the two, the American Revolution started with a limited monarchy, where as the French Revolution started as an absolute monarchy. Which then the rebellion led to violence amongst the government and the people. Similarities can be determined by realizing the common inspiration that drove their revolutionary actions. Both nations were also experiencing mercantilism by their mother colonies, Spain and Great Britain, and wanted to free themselves and control their own economies. R3B#W\VEVtl:iMn3(P"wDCjZQcz=*\$&sD$ r@\NE^~F54k,AL9C8 In the American Revolution, colonists were rebelling against their ruler. We see this in the American Declaration of Independence and the French Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, both of which express Enlightenment ideas about fundamental human rights. By the 1900s many Latin American countries were form. The North American and Spanish American Revolutions were similar in that they both shared the common goal of liberation from the foreign colonial governments that ruled over them. Cornwallis The leader of Britian in the American Revolution. There were three different social groups and the lowest group, which consisted of peasants and the middle class, were burdened by heavy taxation. WebThe similarities of the American Revolution and the French revolution can be seen by examining the root causes, the rebels, and the lasting impact of both revolutions. The world was shocked at the success of the American Revolution, in which the oppressed colonies gained independence from Britain. WebHistorical Era: Revolution and the New Nation (1754-1820s) This activity engages students in a comparison of the American Declaration of Independence and the French Declaration of Rights of Man and Citizen. After the war, the British government was in immediate need of money, and they felt that they had let the colonies loose for too long. One of the many differences between the American and French Revolutions is that, unlike the French, Americans did not fight for an abstraction. George III wanted to recapture the absolute power over his kingdom. WebThe French Revolution and the American Revolution, had many similarities and differences. Both revolutions What is george calvert's american colony. That is what both colonial America, and France did. The revolutions both have many similarities and differences. This is significant because both revolutions had this connection. (2021, May 30). Simultaneously, colonists who owned property began to work their way into government and public affairs. WebThe French Revolution of 1789 was one of mass chaos. The revolution and American War of Independence were the samples of civilians rebellion against their regime. Once America was finally free, its people created a brand new society that was built on the idea of equality. perfect equality would be inconsistent with liberty? That is definitely true but only for individual liberty, not corporate liberty. Latest answer posted October 06, 2019 at 11:40:56 AM. The British were busy exploiting and controlling the Natives, which eventually led to them rebelling. While Frances focus has not changed, Americas destiny is now shaped by anonymous market forces, public relations specialists, lobbyists, investors, a vastly richer, more influential corporate overclass directly implicated in politics, etc. He was interested in weakening England (a longtime rival) and thus contributed financially to the American Revolution, leaving France in debt. Economic problems for the French political economy of the was tragic. The slogan no taxation without representation aptly summed up one of their chief complaints. Each country won their revolutions; Besides, France, wished a brand new government and extra money and food offer; but the America simply wished their independence from land; but America was burdensome issues and numbers from land that were laborious on them; and France were those laborious on others for cash to refill them provides., Between the years 1750 - 1914, the American Revolution, French Revolution, and Haitian Revolution were all similar due to what sparked the revolutions and the social groups during, yet differed in the outcome of the revolutions. The economic changes allowed the U.S to advance as a country, however there were some problems with equality. In France, although the land was large, there wasnt any body of water separating the rule. Even though, The American and Venezuelan revolution took place in different time period, there were similar reason for resistance/rebellions in colonies to become an Independent Nation and carry out equality and Freedom. The difference between the American, Russian, and French revolution is the context in which they were caused by because each of them fought for their own struggles and had a different opinion on how their country was overseen and ruled. Sadly, Toussaint could not see his revolution till the end because Napoleon captured him and held him in a French open air prison until he died in 1803, one year before his successor, Jean-Jacques Dessalines, declared Haiti a sovereign state. ? The revolutions truly are the same scenario played out in different, There were a few main points that led up to the Latin American independence movement. The American Revolution was triggered by the American colonists need for financial independence from the overpowering nation of Great Britain, while the French revolution was a struggle to gain social equality among the masses. These revolutions were similar in a way, because they both were fighting against their suppressing powers and one difference was the way that unity shaped the way they gained independence. There were acts passed that required goods and products going in and out of American ports need to pay a tax, but being 5,000 miles away from the authorities, many merchants were able to get away with smuggling. The similarities of the French Revolution and the American revolution was both sought a change for their government and economic conditions. The Imaginative Conservativeapplies the principle of appreciation to the discussion of culture and politicswe approach dialogue with magnanimity rather than with mere civility. That is a distortion. Log in here. Both revolutions are known for successfully abolishing their former absolute monarchies to constitutional monarchies and democracies. In conclusion, there was great strife and terror that went on during this time in history, but the greatness the revolutionary groups will forever be remembered. Enlightenment ideas began after the Scientific Revolution in Europe, when people began to question tradition. However, all three revolutions were similar in that they were driven by people questioning tyrannical governments and traditional power structures based on new ideas. WebExplains that the american and french revolutions share many similarities, but both events have distinct differences. Very similar to Russia, one of the causes of the French Revolution was that the economy was struggling dramatically especially with produce. This is significant because the French rebels did not have a navy as the Americans had a navy. They understood that they were signing their names to a document that simply explained why it had become necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another and that declared the causes which impel them to the separation. The Declaration was a document of dissolution. Amazing article! In the same way American colonists were being taxed for every purchase of a British good. Some historians have argued that the American Revolution featured less internal disagreement and strife than the French and Haitian Revolutions, but others tend to disagree, citing many places (like the South) where the Revolution was basically a civil war between Whigs and Loyalists.. The relationship between those expanding West and the Indians is the same as between any high-tech society meeting a low-tech society in history. One of their similarities included that both nations were against the harsh rule by their kings. The French Revolution was mainly within the country on France. Instead, it led them to descend into the Terror, the reign of Napoleon, and, ultimately, to the restoration of the monarchy. WebThere were many similarities and differences between the American and French Revolution. Both of the revolutions were liberating, but the French revolution was more violent and WebThe American and French revolutions are similar in some ways but different in others. In the same manner, the muskets and artillery were used to attack each other into submission. The French and American revolution had similarities and differences. The French Revolution established abstract universalistic principles based on a responsibility to human rights, while the Americans preferred to focus on immediate problem-solving and rights (to land they took from the natives.) They were all part of the Age of Revolutionsa historical period (17741849) marked by a significant number of revolutionary movements inspired by the ideas of philosophes like John Locke, Baron de Montesquieu, Voltaire, and Beccaria. Reason may mislead us.[1]They sought not to create something new under the sun. When Louis XVI came to power, France was in deep financial trouble. A bread riot began in both cases. Furthermore, religious and civic ritual of all kinds constantly stressed the centrality of the Spanish king to the colonial commonwealth, and his benevolence and fatherly concern with the welfare of his weakest subjects (Van Young 155). Just like France, the American colonists were composed up mainly middle and lower class citizens. The CHOICE to engage in a trade relationship cannot be abused or manipulated, lest it ceases to be trade and becomes coercion. Second, is that both revolutions momentum behind their uprisings was unfair taxation. He has published seven books and scores of essays on early American history. The American Revolutionary War took place in thirteen colonies, in North America, an ocean away from its ruling monarchy in Great Britain, in Europe. During the 18th and 19th century, from 1776 to 1804, two nations were fighting for their independence. WebDifferences And Similarities Between The American And The French Revolution. The American, French, and Haitian Revolutions had much in common, as each was inspired by a desire to overthrow a ruler and bolstered by Enlightenment thought. In contrast, although Mexico did have conservatives that wished to stay a colony of Spain, the vast majority of people, regardless of social class, opposed the dictator. The French, on the other hand, deified Reason above not only experience, but also above religion and divine revelation. The Latin American revolution as well as the Haitian revolution were led to gain independence from the colonial power of France, Spain, and Portugal. To end absolute monarchy, the church powers needed to be limited. The colonists wrote up the Declaration of Independence, thus beginning the war portion of the American Revolution. Let us know your assignment type and we'll make sure to get you exactly the kind of answer you need. This action angered the citizens especially the colonists because they had no one to represent them and fight for them in Parliament. It has been brightened for clarity. Wendell Berry was right about abstraction: abstraction is the enemywhereverit is found.[4]Let us turn instead, as Americas Founders did, to experience. Smuggling activities were many at the time, but British took control of it. No King but King Jesus is the more accurate battle cry of the American Revolution. "What do the American, French, and Haitian Revolutions have in common? The French had already discovered and claimed a massive region of North America, stretching from Louisiana in the South to the Canadian border in the north. In the end the French lost the having to hand over, After years of battling the English both on and off the battlefield, America was finally crowned the victor. Great job. Another difference is in the locations of these two countries. Comparison between both revolutions was that, both were depended on equal rights, radicalism, thoughts from the awareness against dictator control, majority rule government; engaged Wondering if anyone would agree that the French also started their revolution with greater challenges to face? The difference between the American, Russian, and French revolution is the context in which they were caused by because each of them fought for their own struggles and had a different opinion on how their country was overseen and ruled. Because a few dared to dream and stand up for what was right, we all have our freedom today. Benjamin Franklin, George Washington, John Locke all contributed to revolutionary ideas. WebDespite the similarities in the causes, the consequences of both revolutions were radically different when it came to the outcomes of the war, with France having a constitutional monarchy while Latin America was free from Spanish rule, however, never being able to unify as a show more content One similarity is that in each revolution, people were fighting for freedom from some kind of oppressive rule, at least in the minds of those who were fighting for their freedom. The French Revolution was an important age of political and social turmoil in France that lasted from 1789 to 1799. Differences Between French, Russian and American Revolutions. It started because the American colonists were tired of the tyrannical King George III, who was taxing the them without allowing for the colonists to have proper representation in Englands parliament. Whereas Americans struggled for tangible goals, the French took on the Sisyphean task of striving for abstractions. Their Their academic data culminates in consensus on varied revolutionary social, political and economic As seen previously in Britain, France was at a money deficit partially due to war, but also due to unnecessary spending. Perfect equality is elusive and, even if it could be achieved, would be inconsistent with liberty. How is it that France is so unsuccessful compared to the Latin American Revolution which had similar causes? Although it was considered to be over, the country was still uneasy after the death of Napoleon. But you can one from professional essay writers. This success, along with several other causes, motivated the oppressed lower class of France to have their own revolution. Although they had similar goals, the consequences of these events were different. They did this to permanently remove the power of Church authority within the government.